Another strawman definition of feminism

In the Telegraph today, Bryony Gordon has managed to simultaneously portray feminism as a man-hating, uncompromising ideological stance, and to suggest some rather dull self-evident truths are the answer to all relationship issues.  Ms Gordon is ostensibly supporting Kirstie Allsopp’s statement that women should put their men first.  In the Daily Mail, Ms Allsopp is quoted as saying “if you do what your partner prefers, he is happy and the children have a great time too”.

I don’t know what Ms Allsopp really means by this, as newspapers have a habit of taking quotes out of context and people have a tendency to hear what they want to hear.  Certainly the Daily Mail article suggests a little further down that that “doing what your partner prefers” refers to choosing weekend activities, rather than life-changing decisions such getting a mortgage or emigrating.

Both articles hold up a strawman concept of feminism.  Feminists, they say, are not nice to men.  In fact, it’s right there in the fifth paragraph of the Telegraph article!  Ms Gordon enlightens us that “It’s OK to be nice to men. It’s fine to put a wash on for them, iron their shirts, or sew up a pair of split trousers. It’s OK to cook for them, and occasionally shop for them. You don’t have to feel like a terrible failure if you clean up after them.”

Of course it’s fine to be nice to other people.  Of course it’s fine to do things for your partner.  And no, Ms Gordon, this isn’t about “using your feminine wiles to get the best out of a relationship”.  This is about two people living together.  If one person isn’t pulling their weight, then you might have a relationship problem, but that problem doesn’t need to be gendered.  Domestic equality isn’t about dividing the household responsibilities exactly down the middle, but about reaching a place of understanding.  It’s about compromise – you choose the Saturday treats and I’ll choose our holiday, or you do the washing-up and I’ll do the ironing.

Being in a relationship with another person means that you always consider their needs – although occassionally you decide to put your own needs first.  Really, this isn’t about being a wife or a girlfriend, but about being a partner.  This isn’t about feminism, and Ms Gordon should know it.  Stop burning strawmen.


About feminismfortories

Moderate Tory, Liberal Feminist. Based in the UK.
This entry was posted in Definitions, Foolish comments, Media, society and state and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Another strawman definition of feminism

  1. Bryony Gordon’s article makes the classic mistake of sexists which is to chuck gender into the equation at random.

    Everything she says (compromise with your partner, sometimes do their laundry, sometimes do what they want to do, etc) applies to gay and lesbian couples too!

    I am happy to sometimes do what a partner wants, as long as they sometimes do the same sometimes. Same goes for friends and family. Gender is irrelevant.

  2. Pingback: Another strawman definition of feminism | Feminism For Tories | Feminist definition of life and living well |

  3. MadamJMo says:

    Excellent post. Thoroughly agree.

    The Telegraph’s understanding of feminism is frightening at best, and dangerous at worst. Kirstie Allsop with her ‘home made home’ type programmes has no concept of what life is like for women who were not born into wealthy families, who have to go out to work every day, before coming home to a small house, an equally tired partner and demanding kids, and a dog that needs a long walk! Women who don’t have time to sew a quilt or throw their own pottery plates. Which Kirstie paints as the ideal way for a perfect wife to behave.

    Relationships in 2011 are all about compromise, respect and compassion. We are (almost) all busy people who are time poor, cash poor – something Kirstie, Bryony and the Telegraph might do well to remember.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s